By now, this screenshot will be familiar to many:
|Fox News screenshot, as reported by Newsweek|
and everybody else.
I have a few thoughts, in no particular order, other than the first:
- I am glad so many of my friends thought of my efforts in geographic education when they saw this.
- I am also reminded that our most prolific geographer -- the late, great Dr. Harm de Blij -- told us that he wrote 1,000 letters a year to public officials and the editors of various programs and publications about errors of this kind or erroneous maps. Some stand out more than others, but many are made. Dr. de Blij, incidentally, was the first person to put a map of Kuwait on television when Iraq invaded it; he knew instantly that it would be an example of Americans learning geography through war.
And some more thoughts:
- We wonder why Americans are so bad at geography, but we don't actually teach it much. The world is big and complicated; it needs more than a quick class in middle school. Massachusetts is about to increase it from a miniscule part of the curriculum to a tiny part. We need more, but someone in state government is working very hard against us.
- It remains illegal to become a certified high-school geography teacher in Massachusetts.
- Seeing this post did motivate me to get the publicity together for our next advocacy day (April 17, 2019) at the State House.
|Photo by BSU Alumna Ashley (Costa) Harris|
Massachusetts State House 2012
As published in National Geographic's
Geography for Life
And two more thoughts about the story:
- The xenophobia of the people involved is giving the quote more attention.
- The attention is a distraction from the important part of the story, which is the application of hamfisted negotiation tactics to a matter of extreme complexity in the international sphere.
My doctoral minor in Latin American Area Studies can now be called Mexico & Stuff.
The essential site Latino Rebels provides an antidote to the ignorance, in the form of a map (hurrah!) and a poem that is as instructive as it is tragic: Central American (In)Visibility.
|Map: Latino Rebels|